Musik / klassiske symfonier

Symphony no. 7


Anmeldelser (56)


MusicWeb international

2016 April

af

af

Michael Cookson

2016 April

"This exciting release of the celebrated and the little known contains live Dresden accounts ... It has become the tradition at Dresden for Thielemann to open each season with a Bruckner symphony ... Thielemann is nothing if not gripping and there's a considerable spirituality about what we hear that can leave a powerful effect on the listener ... With this outstanding live performance Thielemann and his Staatskapelle demonstrate that they are more than a match for any of the competition ... There is much impressively unified singing in the Liebesmahl ... Thielemann does a sterling job bringing his orchestral and choral forces together so proficiently ... Given memorable performances Bruckner and Wagner devotees should not hesitate over this most impressive release".


Presto classical

d. 20. apr. 2018

af

af

James Longstaffe

d. 20. apr. 2018

"Recording of the week: What elevates these performances for me is the fact that Nelsons takes equal care over the string parts ... Having said that, the brass certainly don't disappoint either: the outbursts of the slow movement of the Seventh are handled extremely well, with a beautifully-paced series of cadences that culminates in an ecstatic climax ... This is shaping up to be a fine modern cycle, and I continue to recommend it most highly".


MusicWeb international

2024 October

af

af

Kelvin Chan

2024 October

"Recommended: This is a truly unmissable release that combines this conductor's and ensemble's well-deserved accolades in high and late Romantic repertoire with a much-welcomed advocacy for contemporary orchestral music".


MusicWeb international

2024 September

af

af

John Quinn (musikanmelder)

2024 September

"Recommended: Persuasively interpreted and marvellously played, this is a very distinguished account of the Seventh symphony ... The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra commissioned Mason Bates' Resurrexit to celebrate Manfred Honeck's sixtieth birthday ... It's an attractive, exciting piece ... [It] has great energy and there are vibrant colours in the orchestration ... I liked Bates' piece very much ... This disc is as successful on the technical side as it is on the musical side".


MusicWeb international

2024 August

af

af

Ralph Moore (musikanmelder)

2024 August

"Recording of the month: I have in general been impressed by the performances from Honeck and the Pittsburgh SO; they are in many ways one of the most interesting and rewarding partnerships on the modern classical scene, so I had great expectations of this new release. I was not disappointed; indeed I was immediately gripped ... This now becomes for me the equal of any recording I know; I fact, I am inclined to make it the prime recommendation".


MusicWeb international

2015 April

af

af

Dave Billinge

2015 April

"One of the most striking characteristics of the present performance is the consistency of flow throughout ... and there is no harm done to Bruckner by playing him this way. It could very easily result in a performance without character but here Young shows herself the master of subtlety because her interpretation ... is always absorbing yet never in any way disturbing. She never rushes climaxes".


MusicWeb international

2015 April

af

af

John Quinn (musikanmelder)

2015 April

"Simone Young's performance is spirited and convincing ... I enjoyed this performance very much. I also liked the sound on this SACD which has presence and definition ... A fine addition to Simone Young's Bruckner cycle. Collectors who have been following it need not hesitate to acquire it".


Politiken

d. 19. apr. 2012

af

af

Thomas Michelsen

d. 19. apr. 2012

"Det er tredje gang, Barenboim indspiller Bruckners 7. Symfoni ... Varmen og det fleksible flow er en stor overraskelse - og meget sympatisk ... Musikken sitrer - undskyld klichéen - med en hudløshed, der bærer lytteren vidt vågen og dybt fascineret med sig gennem de små 70 minutter, de fire satser sammen varer".


Kristeligt dagblad

d. 2. maj 2012

af

af

Peter Dürrfeld

d. 2. maj 2012

"Bruckners 7. symfoni blev et sent gennembrud for den særegne østrigske komponist ... Nu har Daniel Barenboim overgået alt og alle med en fabelagtig indspilning, hvor han aflokker sit "husorkester" Staatskapelle Berlin hårrejsende skønne klange. Desuden hænger de fire satser sammen på en forunderlig måde, som kun en maestro med det store overblik kan præstere ... Denne indspilning er en perle af en cd, svær at komme udenom for Brucknerfans".


Jyllands-posten

d. 7. maj 2007

af

af

John Christiansen

d. 7. maj 2007

"Det [Aarhus Symfoniorkester] yder en imponerende præstation, som giver respons til James Loughrans musikalsk mere dybtgående og interessante tolkning. Han forstår at afbalancere og lade temagrupperne belyse hinanden. Det giver ikke blot sammenhæng, men også mere dramatisk liv".


Kristeligt dagblad

d. 28. nov. 2007

af

af

Jakob Holm

d. 28. nov. 2007


Kristeligt dagblad

d. 12. maj 2007

af

af

Bernhard Lewkovitch

d. 12. maj 2007

"Aarhus Symfoniorkester under ledelse af James Loughran lægger kortene på bordet, sådan som de er spillet af Bruckner ... undervejs sker underet. Man fanges, fastholdes og gribes, af musikken af komponisten og de mange forskellige situationer og disses skift, indtil sidste tone klinger af. I mellemtiden har man været på de højeste tinder i dynamisk klangudfoldelse ... hvor der dog spilles herligt".


Diapason

2016 juillet-août

af

af

Rémy Louis

2016 juillet-août


Fono Forum

2016 Juli

af

af

Werner Pfister

2016 Juli

"Wagners Liebesmahl der Apostel ... ein überaus ambitioniertes frühes Werk ... sozusagen eine Vorwegnahme des Parsifal. Alle Chöre singen mit bemerkenswerter Klangschönheit und hingebungsvoller intensität. Darüber vergisst man schnell, dass die rein musikalische Qualität dieses Liebesmahls den Bühnenwerken Wagners in jeder Hinsicht unterlegen ist ... Mit Bruckner ... ein ziemlich pauschaler Bruckner also, trotz hervorragender Orchesterleistungen".


BBC music magazine

2016 August

af

af

Michael Tanner (musikanmelder)

2016 August

"This performance [Bruckner] from the Semperoper om 2012 is stupefying in its grandeur ... The sound he draws from the Staatskapelle on this occasion is astounding ... The Wagner item is a rarity, and should remain one ... It's a lusty work, with some fine things, but mainly a bore and disconcertingly ordinary. Thielemann makes the best possible case for it".


BBC music magazine

2018 September

af

af

Michael Tanner (musikanmelder)

2018 September

"Nelsons is a somewhat variable conductor, though always an interesting one. He seems to take his cue for this symphony from the Funeral March which precedes it, and on the whole his tempos are broad though flexible, and the sound of the magnificent Gewandhausorchester is rich and built from the bottom upwards".


Fono Forum

2018 Juli

af

af

Gerald Felber

2018 Juli

"Die ohrenumarmende Aura des Gewandhausklangs kommt der konzentrierten Entspanntheit und aufmerksamen Gelassenheit des neuen Orchesterchefs bestens entgegen ... Trotzdem: Auch diese Serie bleibt auf der Höhe der Leipziger Bruckner-Tradition".


BBC music magazine

2007 October

af

af

Stephen Johnson (f. 1955)

2007 October

"This is an exceptionally fine Bruckner ... The flowing, finely shaped phrasing, balance of tempo between sections, and unfailing sense of how each section fits into the whole, makes this exceptionally compelling amongst modern versions ... Strongly recommended".


BBC music magazine

2024 October

af

af

Terry Blain

2024 October

"Recording of the month: Manfred Honeck has already released Bruckner's Fourth and Ninth symphonies ... This new Seventh ups the ante further: it's undoubtedly one of the best recordings of the symphony in the digital era ... It's a glowing testament to the high levels of synergy and mutual comprehension that Manfred Honeck and the Pittsburgh Symphony have achieved in his 16 years as music director, particularly in Bruckner".


Fono Forum

2024 Oktober

af

af

Tom Reinhold

2024 Oktober

"Empfehlungen des Monats: Das Pittsburgher Orchester spielt nicht nur, wie alle amerikanischen Spitzenensembles, präzise und mit klangwuchtigem Blech, sondern auch mit europäischer Individualität und Tiefe".


Diapason

2013 mars

af

af

Jean-Claude Hulot

2013 mars


BBC music magazine

2013 January

af

af

Erik Levi

2013 January

"Vurdering: BBC music orchestral choice" - "Runnicles's debut recording for Hyperion is a very impressive achievement. He has established a strong rapport with the BBC Scottish Syphony Orchestra, inspiring them to deliver playing of great refinement and emulating the burnished tones that are more often associated with Central European orchestras ... Hyperion's recording is eminently satisfying ... Highly recommended".


BBC music magazine

2009 August

af

af

Stephen Johnson (f. 1955)

2009 August

"The result is more than interesting. Järvi's view is more a spacious Schubertian landscape than a "cathedral in sound" - and none the worse for that".


Diapason

2014 septembre

af

af

Jean-Claude Hulot

2014 septembre


BBC music magazine

2014 August

af

af

Martin Cotton

2014 August

"The big climax is the one place where I wish that Fischer had taken more time, but it fits in with his concept of the Symphony as a whole".


BBC music magazine

2015 June

af

af

Erik Levi

2015 June

"The playing of the Hamburg Philharmonic is uniformly excellent ... Particularly admirable is the expressive warmth that Young draws from the strings in the central part of the scherzo".


Klassisk

2007, nr. 6

af

af

Steen Chr. Steensen

2007, nr. 6

"Udover at administrere tempobetegnelserne med rund hånd og virkelig tage betegnelsen "sehr langsam" meget bogstaveligt, så har James Loughran en særlig evne til at skabe smuk klang med de midler, han har til sin rådighed. Ikke mindst strygerne klinger smukt og egalt, når de får lejlighed til at folde sig ud ... Et vidnesbyrd om en minderig aften".


Politiken

d. 9. jan. 2000

af

d. 9. jan. 2000


Berlingske tidende

d. 23. feb. 2000

af

d. 23. feb. 2000


High fidelity

2000 6

af

2000 6


Jyllands-posten

d. 7. dec. 1999

af

d. 7. dec. 1999


The gramophone

2016 July

af

af

Christian Hoskins

2016 July

"The contribution of the Staatskapelle Dresden is magnificent, the strings in particular playing with quite exceptional depth of tone and expressiveness ... Dynamic contrasts are carefully observed and the balance between instrumental groups is exemplary ... The recording of both works is first-class".


Politiken

d. 14. maj 2000

af

d. 14. maj 2000


Jyllands-posten

d. 15. aug. 2000

af

d. 15. aug. 2000


Kristeligt dagblad

d. 19. juni 2000

af

d. 19. juni 2000


Berlingske tidende

d. 25. okt. 2000

af

d. 25. okt. 2000


The gramophone

2018 July

af

af

Richard Osborne (f. 1943)

2018 July

"Memorably recordings have been made in recent times ... but how is it that so few latter-day conductors appear able to get line aboard? And 'line' is the operative word, since it's not so much the often doleful tempos which undermine this newest recording as the apparent inability of conductor Andris Nelsons to establish that all-commanding pulse ... Is the problem that too much attention is being lavished on the orchestra ... and not enough on the music?".


Politiken

d. 8. aug. 1999

af

d. 8. aug. 1999


International record review

2007 November

af

af

peter J. Rabinowitz

2007 November

"If you're looking for something a little less individualistic, however, you'll probalbly be well served by Herbert Blomstedt's spacious interpretation, expertly executed by a confident ensemble capable of clear articulation, superb timbral definition and subtle dynamic shading even at the quietest end of the spectrum".


Politiken

d. 30. apr. 2000

af

d. 30. apr. 2000


Jyllands-posten

d. 25. apr. 2000

af

d. 25. apr. 2000


The gramophone

2012 July

af

af

Rob Cowan (f. 1948)

2012 July

"Much of the performance is magical and the tender, warmly cosseting string sound of the Staatskapelle Berlin is of truly vintage quality ... This is an emotionally generous, spontaneous and outstandingly communicative account of the Seventh, I'd say the best that Barenboim has yet given us".


Klassisk

2012, nr. 25

af

af

Per Rask Madsen

2012, nr. 25

"På kun én uge dirigerede han hele seks af Bruckners mastodontiske symfonier og var solist i Beethovens fem klaverkoncerter. Maratonpræstationen medførte nogle resultater, der gør Bruckner-symfonierne mere nuancerede".


The gramophone

2024 September

af

af

Richard Osborne (f. 1943)

2024 September

"Honeck, like Carlo Maria Giulini, began his career as a viola player, which explains why both conduct a Seventh whose defining string sound comes, as it should, from the second violins, violas and cellos. The Pittsburgh players, antiphonally spaced, are superb ... 'Resurrexit', an orchestral meditation on the Easter story painted in Middle Eastern colours, was commissioned for Honeck's 60th birthday in 2018 ... The orchestra play the piece superbly, as I imagine only they can".


The gramophone

2013 January

af

af

Edward Seckerson

2013 January

"The defining character of [Runnicles's] Bruckner on this showing is the singing fluency of the line. Everything has shape and purpose and a naturalness of phrasing ... Those who favour a grander, more expansive, more monolithic approach to this music may find the scale of Runnicles's reading a shade diminishing. But be in no doubt that it is thoughtful and radiant and eminently musical".


The gramophone

2009 September

af

af

Rob Cowan (f. 1948)

2009 September

"Vurdering: Editor's choice" - "Järvi offers an extremely beautiful performance, responsively played and, most crucially, sensitive to key transitions".


The gramophone

2014 August

af

af

Rob Cowan (f. 1948)

2014 August

"Right from the opening pp tremolando you can tell that as an interpretation this is going to be something off the beaten track. Rather than cue the familiar shimmering haze, Fischer prefers a softly undulating chord ... That warmth remains a constant throughout the performance".


International record review

2014 September

af

af

Robert Matthew-Walker

2014 September

"Vurdering: IRR outstanding" - "This is a quite magnificent performance of this immortal masterpiece. from bar to last, Iván Fischer has the measure of the Symphony, exemplified throughout by his superb choice of tempos ... The recording quality is equally of a very high standard".


Berlingske tidende

d. 19. juli 2003

af

d. 19. juli 2003


High fidelity (Kbh.)

Årg. 41, nr. 1 (2008)

af

af

Mogens Wenzel Andreasen

Årg. 41, nr. 1 (2008)

"Dansk Bruckner ... og det er bemærkelsesværdig godt. En bred, næsten sakralt klingende Bruckner, med rolige stigninger til de vældige højdepunkter og en apoteotisk finale, som får én til at rette sig op i stolen ... Orkesterspillet er i topklasse, man mærker knap, at det er en koncertoptagelse ... Anbefales!".


The gramophone

2011 September

af

af

Rob Cowan (f. 1948)

2011 September

"Petatone has provided excellent sound. This is yet another significant step towards what I am convinced will eventually turn out to be one of the finest recorded Bruckner cycles of the 21st century".


International record review

2011 September

af

af

Robert Matthew-Walker

2011 September

"All in all, this is a most beautifully recorded and deeply impressive issue all true Brucknerians will want to possess".



Informationer og udgaver