Music / opera

Amadigi


Reviews (6)


AllMusic

2008

By

By

Stephen Eddins

2008

"The soloists, sopranos Elena de la Merced and Sharon Rostorf-Zamir, mezzo Maria Riccarda Wesseling, and countertenor Jordi Domènech are hardly household names, but all have full, richly modulated voices, and are fully invested in the drama. Al Ayre Español, led by Eduardo López Banzo, plays with beautiful tone, high spirits, and dramatic nuance — the musical performances are altogether first rate and fully satisfying".


The guardian

d. 15. Sep. 2022

By

By

Erica Jeal

d. 15. Sep. 2022

"It's odd that Handel's Amadigi isn't better known, given what it has going for it. For a start it's short, for a Handel opera (these things are relative), and compact, with only four characters ... All the roles are for high voices, which could have made for unvaried home listening, but there's an effective contrast between the liquid tone of Tim Mead's countertenor in the title role and the distinctive steel-cored contralto of Hilary Summers as his false friend Dardano. The two sopranos, Mary Bevan as Melissa and Anna Dennis as Oriana, are closer in tone but both respond with some glorious singing to the way Handel's music draws their differing characters ... Not so straightforward after all - and this recording should help win the opera some new friends".


BBC music magazine

2008 March

By

By

Nicholas Anderson

2008 March

"Vurdering: BBC music choice" - "It's almost 20 years since Marc Minkowski made his recording of Handel's "magic" opera, Amadigi di Gaula (1715). None has appeared commercially since then, so this new release is especially welcome ... I doubt very much if readers will be disappointed either by the singing and sympathetic instrumental playing, or by Handel's consistenly beguiling, often sensuous music".


BBC music magazine

2022 November

By

By

Berta Joncus

2022 November

"Opera choice: Handel took a less-is-more approach to his Amadigi di Gaula. Christian Curnyn's answering restraint reveals the stark solos, shimmering textures, ringing silences and stunning one-to-a-part counterpoint of music that fairly bursts with its composer's early genius ... At the centre of the drama is Melissa, sung by Mary Bevan with transfixing intensity ... Tim Mead gives depth to Amadigi ... The instrumentalists' playing is revelatory, the grace they bring to vocal-woodwind exchanges ... make this a memorable performance".


Diapason

2022 decembre

By

By

Luca Dupont-Spirio

2022 decembre


The gramophone

2022 November

By

By

Richard Wigmore

2022 November

"Editor's choice: 'Amaldigi' has always remained on the Handelian margins. One reason, perhaps, is that it contains no parts for tenors or basses. There are flaws in pacing and dramatic logic ... The level of musical intention is consistently high, above all in the many slow, introspective arias in which Handel was supreme ... The playing of Curnyn's Early Opera Company, technically impeccable, has that much more colour and fire than Minkowski's Musiciens du Louvre. Curnyn's cast of expert Handelians is self-recommending. In a performance both commanding and sympathetic, Mary Bevan catches each fluctuating emotion of Handel's scorned sorceress ... The close dramatic interplay between voice and orchestra is a prime feature of this whole, superb performance".