"A failure, a brief success, then a gap of 127 years: that was the pattern for Caterina Cornaro ... but now Opera Rara swells its Donizetti catalogue with this new set ... If Opera Rara's cast does not boast names as internationally known ... it does provide much pleasure ... [Colin Lee] is up to his usual high standard. His bright, high-placed voice is in fine condition ... There are some meaty morsels for the middle of Giannattasio's compass, which she treats to the occasional touch of chest-voice, yet she can take upward flight with flowing ease ... She completes a fine cast, in which there is no weakness".